• 6 Posts
  • 787 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: September 12th, 2023

help-circle


  • NOT the person you’re replying to.

    You, rightly imnsho, got a snarky response because you weren’t just asking a question.

    This (below) is fine

    What exactly is the risk to the ecosystem?

    This (below) earned you the snark.

    Since you’re okay with it, you should know what it is, right?

    That reads very clearly as “I don’t think you know shit, prove it, and unless you do, you don’t have a right to an opinion”

    You didn’t know whether OP did or did not have a handle on the ecological impact. Either stop at the first bit, or word the second less aggressively.

    Feedback is being provided here because you are taking an overt “I was just asking a question why are you snarking stance”. If that’s fake then I’ll just block and move on.



  • california doesnt seem to have an endemic mosquito borne disease problem, florida does though.

    I’m not American so excuse my ignorance, but I was under the impression that Florida was full of swamps and low lying (fresh-ish) water whereas California was significantly drier, with most water in rivers.

    The former is an ideal breeding ground for mosquitos (still or stagnant fresh or brackish water), whereas running water and oceans are extremely poor for mosquito breeding.

    Seems pretty clear why Florida (and Mississipi etc) have a bigger mosquito problem to me - what am I missing ?



  • The ecosystem risk is that a reduction in A. Aegpyti population causes a collapse of the insectivores that depend on consuming it and thus starve, with a knock on effect up the food chain.

    While this may happen, a) predation is not currently any real constraint on the population, and b) other insects have been shown to be able to take up part of the niche and c) this already an ecosystem which been rebalanced - they are not naturally occurring in the US they have travelled over with humans

    Google is thoroughly evil, and I upvoted the cynical parent comment, but on this one subject they are on the right side of the ledger.

    Other non disease carrying mosquitos can take over the ecological niche for a net benefit to humanity.