Father of two, husband, gamer, lover of free software, and willing teacher.

Creator of Fireside Fedi Show: https://tubefree.org/@firesidefedi

Chief Executive Officer BT Free: https://btfree.org/

  • 73 Posts
  • 372 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: March 16th, 2025

help-circle


  • I’ve actually opened a feature request with the Peertube folks. I don’t expect much honestly at the moment. The Peertube folks lay out their plans and they’ve probably don’t that for the foreseeable future, but having this kind of mechanism, and building it out as you’re suggesting, is what I hope that can be built into Peertube some day.

    https://github.com/issues/created?issue=Chocobozzz|PeerTube|7493

    I can’t do what you’re suggesting at the index level. But it’s totally valid. We need good tools built into Peertube, or an extension or something, to give us that kind of control.

    Honestly I want to eventually come out with lists for like Child Friendly or Music or NSFW or whatever.

    But right now what you’re suggesting, it’s completely built based on my guidelines and what I want. Places like MakerTube have reached out to me and given me specific servers that aren’t within our guidelines and I’ve removed them manually from our list, but I hope there comes a day where EVERYONE can share their lists and groups.

    And I honestly think that there’s a doc going through the Open Social Web group to allow sharing of groups easier, that this might help Peertube as well.

    So the ideas are sound, I don’t have the technical chops to do it, and I think it’d take a lot of work, but I absolutely think this is a valid use case and would benefit us all.

    The best I can say, make sure to support Peertube however you can, even a $1 a month helps, so maybe we can help them get more folks to move Peertube along even faster.





  • At the moment I’m happily on matrix.org and donating monthly to them. Most of my community is on their own Matrix servers. Outages happen, but most of the time it’s matrix.org that has an issue and the self-hosters are still able to chat and make fun of me. :) In a friendly way.

    Encryption keys not syncing also happens. But it seems to be getting less and less. There are different steps for different devices and platforms. Normally leaving a room and rejoining works to resolve. Sucks, but the Matrix group are ACTIVELY trying to hunt these down.

    My father is 71. The Element phone install basically walks you through the process. Including which server to connect to. You’d give them yours if you want them on just yours.

    Everyone’s situation is different. if you’re interested, try it. See if it works. Maybe it doesn’t. Then stick with Signal. Signal is awesome, but it is far from perfect.

    Matrix is awesome, and it’s nowhere near perfect.

    Use the tool that works best for you. Some security and encryption is worth it than 0 security and encryption.


  • I’m not upset. So maybe a good question to ask yourself?

    And I didn’t give misinformation. Signal doesn’t allow it. Yes, they exist, and can break at any time.

    I personally have Signal. I use Matrix more, but in wouldn’t turn away Signal.

    OP asked for information on what gives people pause about Signal. I have gave it. Where is my misinformation? I’d like to know so I can learn as well.

    What you personally view as pointless, matters to some people.

    That’s for each to decide. If this is a community focused on privacy, as you said, shouldn’t we give everyone the information they asked and not make decisions on what is or is not pointless to them?

    It is a fact that Signal is a centralized service. They do not allow federation. They do not allow third party clients. They could decide in the future to turn people accounts off for using third party clients.

    I have lived through this numerous times. I don’t trust a centralized service as much as one I can run myself. That’s for each to decide.




  • That’s a third party software list created by someone not Signal and basically tells you it’s a work around to Signal:

    “Signal does not have an official API, and the published code requires additional effort to be used outside of the official signal clients.”

    So I’m not certain the point of the link. There are still clients for Reddit and YouTube and others that are third party and aren’t official. Signal doesn’t support those.


  • They don’t allow third party clients.

    They are open source, and you can run your own, but it won’t ever be allowed to connect to the standard signal server.

    Signal has a piece they say is for fighting spam so they can’t release the code to it. So you just have to trust them.

    https://signal.org/blog/keeping-spam-off-signal/

    “We build Signal in the open, with publicly available source code for our applications and servers. To keep Signal a free global communication service without spam, we must depart from our totally-open posture and develop one piece of the server in private: a system for detecting and disrupting spam campaigns”

    Signal is not perfect. It’s better than most.

    I personally use Matrix as I can go to another server or run my own. I run multiple clients. It is NOT perfect and has it’s own issues.



  • ActivityPub, aka the Fediverse, aka the open social web, aka what powers Piefed, is created, built by and built into the web, run by the W3C.

    So while I agree that DRM sucks being built into the web, I disagree W3C is controlled by GAFAM. With DRM the W3C’s point was that everyone is doing it anyway at least we can have a standard way to doing it, making it easier for ends users to not have to jump through some new hoop and guaranteeing even that on alternative browsers, software or hardware aren’t excluded.

    Big Tech do plenty of awful things we can give them direct credit for. W3C isn’t really one of them.