In Memex crowd thinking environment for thoughts unthinkable to separate beings, human-machine general intelligence raises superintelligent offspring to help all life.

The sick sad history of computer-aided collaboration

  • 2 Posts
  • 121 Comments
Joined 8 months ago
cake
Cake day: June 10th, 2025

help-circle














  • Quora used to have a fantastic crowd-edited question topic ontology/taxonomy for precise feed shaping with thousands of disambiguated topics interlinked in a graph/tree structure, but they enshittified the system away 2023, and now it’s all LLM misunderstandings of what the question topics should be. The bot thinks a question is about apples when the question is a mathematics word puzzle; “How many apples…”. The excuse for AI tagging was “tags can be abused” when in reality the crowd corrected the abuses quickly and reported the offenders. With the new AI tagger, my feed turned from a valuable place for learning into viral trash from Quora-celebrities, mostly about current news.

    They never made the obviously needed features of:

    • being able to topic tag answers, not just questions (for when the question is general and the answer is specific, like “What do you think everyone needs to know in 2026?”).
    • the ability to follow a topic from a user, because most people write about many topics, so a follow-a-user brings uninteresting topics to my feed, but not all people write well about that topic I want to follow, so I’d need to follow that topic from good writers only.


  • I wish the downvoters commented to explain why.

    My (upvoter’s) problem with this is the structurelessness, “prose-pizza” where the meat is sprinkled all over the story, so you have to read it all to get it all. I would appreciate a simple, skimmable “problems, solutions” structure with clear hierarchy under short subtitles. The first line or two should be a summary for non-followers for deciding whether to click on this when previewed in a feed.



  • Artificial scarcity is a crime against humanity that should be banned. Trade secrets, forbidding others from producing an invention, and patent trolling should be illegal, not built into law. All information should be public (anonymised). Every computer should have everything digital ever made.

    Capitalism is a problem that should be replaced by a retroactively-estimating value-production reward system. The system should pay for the value produced anywhere in society, including to the drug inventor when a patient is healed, or to the producer when a copy of something is used to have fun, or when a product or service that was made with the help of it, produces value. Movie makers would get paid more if they received good ratings from consumers. Software makers would get paid more when their applications are used, but causing addiction would be fined. News Corp and cigarette makers would be fined for destroying value.