• 3 Posts
  • 23 Comments
Joined 1 month ago
cake
Cake day: July 22nd, 2026

help-circle





  • The question is not whether a peasant could be an interesting character. Obviously they could. A talented writer could make almost anyone’s life compelling. The question is whether that perspective serves the story being told.

    ASOIAF is a story about political power. The people who have the ability to affect those outcomes are the obvious focus.

    A peon’s POV would be telling a different story and shift the focus from the people competing to the people living with the consequences of the competition. That could be a great novel, but it would not advance the retelling of the dynastic struggle for control of Westeros.

    This is why I asked why you find the absence of lower-class POVs surprising. It seems like an obvious consequence of the scope and focus of the story.